The smell walking into this cookie shop in Milford is the absolutely most amazing thing.

It’s spectacular.

Walk in, deep breaths.

We came looking for the best chocolate chip cookie in Connecticut.

Chocolate Chip Cookie

The cookie itself is huge.

They have lots of options for cookies, and based on the smell we wanted to try them all.

I fear, however, that chocolate chip might not be their best.

First, the cookies are very crispy, not just the edges but the whole thing.

The cookie insides are also a bit dry and not as buttery as one would hope.

The chocolate flavor is really good, but as an overall cookie it’s nice, not great.

This means that probably we will have to come back and get a cookie with a chocolate base.

Not a bad thing.

The Rating: Chocolate Chip Cookie


Kathy’s Famous Cookies

Address: 1365 New Haven Ave, Milford, CT 06460
Hours: Sunday 8am to 4pm
Monday to Friday 7am to 6pm
Saturday 8am to 6pm