On the search for the best ice cream in Connecticut brings us to Wentworth Homemade Ice Cream in Hamden.

The Coffee Oreo is supposedly the one to get.

Whoever said it, is right.

There is a strong bitter flavor from the coffee that is almost too strong and bitter.


What saves it is the constant oreo throughout.

There is so much oreo it’s almost half of every bite.

But the two mixed makes for an average bite that is not too sweet, not too bitter.

Balanced, in a weird way.

The ice cream is super thick, with no grit and no excessive pull.

It’s just ice cream done right.

And the flavor is something to behold.

The Rating:



Wentworth Homemade Ice Cream

3697 Whitney Ave, Hamden, CT 06518
Open Monday-Friday: 2pm-9pm

Saturday 12pm-9pm

Closed Sunday
Phone: (203) 281-7429